Review the consequence of a claim
AI assistance can produce fluent sentences before anyone has checked whether they are true. An editorial review should therefore begin with consequences: what might a reader do after trusting this passage? A mistaken installation step, invented price, or unsupported safety claim deserves more scrutiny than an awkward transition.
Separate the draft into factual claims, interpretations, and recommendations. This does not require tagging every sentence publicly. It gives the reviewer a practical map of what needs evidence, what needs cautious wording, and what requires a qualified subject expert before release.
Build an evidence trail that survives editing
For each material claim, save a primary source and the precise passage that supports it. A plausible URL is not evidence until someone opens and checks it. Verify that the source supports the actual sentence, including its scope, conditions, and exceptions.
For example, a draft might say that a setting is available to every account. A help page describing one plan supports a narrower statement. Correct the sentence to match the documented scope, or remove it while the product owner verifies availability. Do not repair uncertainty with confident adjectives.
Check originality at the level of contribution
Rephrasing existing pages does not automatically create a useful article. Ask what the reader gains here: a tested procedure, a clear decision framework, a worked example, or an explanation of an overlooked tradeoff. The answer should be visible in the draft rather than promised in its introduction.
Compare distinctive phrases and examples against the supplied source material. Remove borrowed storytelling that implies firsthand experience. An illustrative scenario is acceptable when labeled clearly, but it must not masquerade as a customer interview, a measured result, or a quotation from an employee.
Run the instructions as a reader would
A how-to article should survive a realistic walkthrough. Use a safe test context, follow the written order, and record prerequisites the draft assumes without saying. If verification requires privileged access, arrange an authorized reviewer rather than treating an inaccessible step as completed.
For a content export guide, the reviewer can use this checklist to expose missing detail. The resulting notes should change the instructions, not merely sit in an internal approval thread that the eventual reader cannot see.
- Confirm which permissions and source format the procedure requires.
- Try a small sample and check whether links, labels, and character encoding survive.
- Describe the recovery step if the export is incomplete or contains private fields.
Assign publication and correction ownership
Name an accountable editor in the internal workflow, even when several people use an assistant to draft or revise. That editor should know which claims remain unresolved and who can approve them. Automated drafting does not transfer responsibility to the model or the tool vendor.
Keep a correction path after publication. Preserve the reviewed version, record substantive changes, and route reader reports to someone who can act. When a source changes, reassess the affected recommendation instead of updating a date while leaving the advice untouched.
Avoid unsupported conclusions about discovery
An editorial checklist cannot guarantee search placement, AI citations, or commercial results. Nor should a team assume a universal penalty merely because an assistant helped write a page. Assess the published material through its support, usefulness, and maintenance, while treating distribution outcomes as a separate observation.
Some errors will escape review, especially in specialist topics or fast-changing products. Escalate uncertainty where the consequence matters and narrow claims where verification is unavailable. A shorter accurate explanation often serves readers better than a comprehensive-looking draft whose central instructions cannot be defended.